My best friend and I had a great discussion today. I know she’ll be laughing when she reads this because it only happened an hour ago.
Anyway – our argument was about people, or characters, and “acting out of character”. The discussion started when I menioned characters should always act in character. Her point was that there is so much that we don’t know about ourselves, much less others, that how can we say in an extreme situation what would be “in character”?
Her point is definitely a good one. How do we know what we would act like or be like in an extreme situation? Example, prison. Or in a plane taken over by terrorists? Burning building? Would you do what you could to save yourself, or become a hero? We’d all like to think we’d do the “right” thing. But we don’t really know.
My point was that for the most part people do seem to stay “within” character. My best friend is stubborn, dedicated and has a will of iron. She is that way with books, writing, crazy diets, thriatholons…etc. That’s who she is. I have no doubt if she went prison she would own the place and i’d be her bitch. Because that’s who she is. Now, is it possible that she’d go to prison and deterioate into a whimpering, frightened kitten? Well, maybe. But highly doubtful. She’d most likely still be who she is at her core.
Me? Well, I’ve been in a few situations that I would consider “extreme” in terms of what I’ve been through in my life. Now, me regular? I’m bossy or in a kinder tone, I take charge. It’s what I do best, it’s what I love to do. Gather information and make a decision. It’s also what I do for a living.
Now we had a fairly impressive earthquake in 1989. Loma Prieta. I remember I was going to do some sort of special sleeping in the extra room adventure with my little brother who was about 4 at the time. Earthquake hits. What do I do? I run for the doorway, then start screaming at Jason to join me. He sits in bed with his eyes wide and doesn’t move a muscle. Another example. The chicken my Mom was cooking catches on fire. She starts screaming and running back and forth in front of the flames as if every time she reached the end of the kitchen she realized she needed to go the other way. Meanwhile I calmly assess that nothing is going to catch fire, and I go out into the hallway and let my Dad know. I wasn’t sure if it was a grease fire or not, so I didn’t know if water would help or if I should use baking soda. My brother, older at the time, calmly got the fire extinguisher out of the garage.
That’s me. Calm. Take charge. It’s just a part of who I am. Are there times that I get really flustered and upset? LOL, I’d say yes. Usually when someone won’t follow the instructions I’m giving them. But, I’m still being my bossy self.
Ok, so people, here is the question:
In most situations do people tend to stay within their personalities OR do people vary “out of character” often enough that you can never really say what someone will do?